Clubhouse: Have celebrities done more harm than good?

ON THIS PAGE

A visit to Clubhouse these days feels like a visit to ghost town. Very few interesting conversations and importantly, none of the celebrities are to be seen there.

Rewind to 4 weeks and we had Elon Musk, Zuck, Naval et al organizing these lavish parties and we all stood up outside the gate to join those thousands of listeners.

And much of this is attributed to the star power which A16Z gang brought to Clubhouse – pretty much the entire Silicon Valley!

They are gone. And so is everybody. No parties. No fun. No real talks.

Clubhouse was also competing with conferences. It almost took inspiration from these high-profile conferences, where people attend to listen to big celebrities, network with people who are just like them, ahev their wine and go back.

Just that, unlike these conferences, there is very little post-event networking and friendships.

I am not referring to just the Indian market, but also the global conversations – there are very few great clubs happening now.

What gives?

Well, I am no expert in human psychology, but I believe the celebrity power of Clubhouse GTM has brought in more consumers than producers. I am talking about the intent of usage, which pretty much defines how you will use the product in the long run.

Most now see Clubhouse as a place to listen to celebrities and not a place to talk to people who are like you.

Your community. Your friends. People who are at max 2-3 years senior in the career/startup / life ladder and the ones with whom you wanted to network – you don’t talk to them on Clubhouse.

You don’t talk because they don’t talk. They don’t talk because they are all waiting for Naval and Sriram to talk or bring celebrity guests.

Question : How many of you have ever tried creating your own room at Clubhouse?

The default behavior is to join a celebrity talk show, listen and that’s it.

Almost feels like a rock band that is not gonna play because the lead guitarist and singer are missing.

The audience does not know that they can have fun either ways also. They can sing their own song, play their own music.

The club offers them guitars, drums and all sorts of instrument.

But they are waiting…waiting for the show to begin.


Will the Android app launch bring back the zing? Well, my guess is as good as yours. Wait..let’s talk about it @Clubhouse 🙂

PS: I run a Sunday newsletter for ProductGeeks. Join in.

Email address
First name (Optional)
Last name (Optional)

Make sense of what's next.

A clear-eyed digest of AI, products, and ideas worth understanding. Join the NextBigWhat newsletter.

more AI news

Google launches synth-id to identify AI-generated content

Google has introduced a standalone platform called SynthID Detector, designed to help users determine if online content was generated using Google AI or its partner tools. This initiative aims to enhance transparency and trust in digital content, amidst growing concerns about the authenticity of AI-generated materials. The tool reflects Google’s commitment to ethical AI usage and the accountability of content creators.

US halts green card access for major IT firms amid H-1B abuse claims

The US Department of Labor has suspended major tech companies, including Microsoft, Infosys, and Cognizant, from the green card program due to allegations of H-1B visa abuse. This decision impacts several prominent IT firms such as TCS, Wipro, and Capgemini, potentially affecting their ability to recruit foreign talent. The move underscores increasing scrutiny on visa practices within the tech industry.

Amazon cuts ties with Meta’s Muse AI over transparency issues

Amazon has terminated its partnership with Meta’s Muse AI shopping agent, citing concerns over the agent’s credentials and transparency. This decision reflects Amazon’s commitment to safeguarding its customer journey and maintaining control over its retail ecosystem. The move highlights the ongoing scrutiny of AI tools in e-commerce and their impact on customer trust.